Establishment of a scientific evaluation system to eliminate misunderstanding of evaluating the quality of academic papers
LI Zhe-feng,ZHU Ping(Editorial Department of Journals,Baoji Uinversity of Arts and Sciences,Baoji 721007,Shaanxi,China)
Aim To analyze the cited papers published in Journal of Baoji University of Arts and Sciences: Natural Science(JBUAS: Nat Sci) and to provide a reference for establishing a scientific evaluation system and further improving the quality of the magazine.Methods Document metrology and CNKI database are used to analyze the cited papers written by authors from Baoji University of Arts and Sciences(BUAS) and published in JBUAS: Nat Sci.;SCI database is used to analyze the cited papers written by authors from Baoji region.Results The 1 434 papers published in JBUAS: Nat Sci were indexed by CNKI database,601 papers,accounting for 41.91% of 1 434,were written by BUAS's authors.544 papers had been cited one time or more times(cited times ≥1),which is 37.94% of 1 434 papers;244 papers(cited times ≥1) were written by BUAS's authors,which constitutes 44.85% of 544 papers and 40.60% of 601 papers respectively.5 101 papers written by BUAS's authors were indexed by CNKI database,but cited papers(cited time ≥1) were 2 157,which makes up 42.29% of 5 101 papers,the cited rate of BUAS authors' papers are higher than the cited rate of papers published in JBUAS: Nat Sci.There are 114 papers(cited times ≥10),19 of which were published in non-core journals,it represents 13.19% of 114 papers and there are only 23 papers(cited times≥20),30.43% papers of which were published in non-core journals.293 papers written by Baoji authors were indexed by SCI database,120 of which were cited(cited times≥1),it is 40.95% of 293 papers.Conclusion "Evaluating paper according to journal published the paper" is not scientific,it is necessary that importance is attached to the cited frequency of academic papers.The best option of academic papers evaluation is to establish an objective,scientific evaluation system to eliminate misunderstanding of evaluating the quality of academic papers.
【CateGory Index】： G353.1