Full-Text Search:
Home|Journal Papers|About CNKI|User Service|FAQ|Contact Us|中文
《Journal of Beijing Normal University(Natural Science)》 2004-02
Add to Favorite Get Latest Update

SHORTCOMINGS OF ANALYTICAL HIERARCHY PROCESS AND THE PATH TO IMPROVE THE METHOD

Wu Dianting 1) Li Dongfang 2) ( 1)School of Geography, Beijing Normal University; 2)Personal Office, Beijing Normal University: 100875, Beijing, China)  
To solve the problems of analytical hierarchy process(AHP), some concrete advices were put forward according to the practice of teacher achievement's assessment. The major advice is to enhance the combination between AHP and fuzzy comprehensive assessment(FCA). At first, as many experts as possible should be invited to improve the quality of judgment matrix. At the same time, the value of quantitative information should be developed efficiently and the quantitative and qualitative information should be synthesized to make the assessment comprehensive. All the methods including AHP and FCA have strong points and shortcomings. If there are many objects to assess and a not so exact result is expected, FCA should be used, but AHP should better be thought about to determine the power of the factors. If there are not so many objects to assess and a very exact result is expected, AHP may be the best method.
【Fund】: 国家自然科学基金西部重点资助项目 ( 90 10 2 0 13)
【CateGory Index】: C934
Download(CAJ format) Download(PDF format)
CAJViewer7.0 supports all the CNKI file formats; AdobeReader only supports the PDF format.
【References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 HOU Li-na et al(School of Economics and Management,Southwest Jiaotong University,Chengdu,Sichuan 610031);Improvement of AHP and Its Application in Sichuan Agricultural Development[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2009-16
2 WANG Kun et al (College of Chemistry and Environmental Engineering,Hubei University for Nationalities,Enshi,Hubei 445000);Soil Quality Assessment of the Planting Base of Amorphophallus Konjac in Enshi Prefecture Based on the Analytic Hierarchy Process[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2010-28
3 LI Shi-mei(Media Management Department,Hunan Mass Media College,Changsha 410100,China);A Research on College Teachers’ Comprehensive Performance Evaluation Based on AHP Model[J];Journal of Changshu Institute of Technology;2008-11
4 LI Xiu-qing1,SHANG Jing-gang1,JIANG Shi-jin2,LIU Zi-jun2,SONG Yun-feng1(1.School of Elec.Eng.,Northeast Dianli University,Jilin 132012,China;2.Jixi Electricity Power Bureau,Jixi 158100,China);Fuzzy interval number based hierarchical analysis process for assessing black-start plans[J];Advanced Technology of Electrical Engineering and Energy;2010-02
5 LI Xiao-Xiao, TAO Fa-Sheng, YOU Hai-Yan Department of Health Service, College of High Altitude Military Medicine, Third Military Medical University, Chongqing 400038, China;Establishment of index system for health service information-based evaluation of military hospitals by improving AHP method[J];Journal of the Fourth Military Medical University;2008-16
6 GUO Xiao-ying,SHEN Zhen-yao,LIN Ting,KUANG Liang (School of Environment,Beijing Normal University,Beijing 100875,China);Classification of Universities'Reclaimed Water Source and Sorting of Exploitability Based on AHP Method[J];Environmental Science & Technology;2010-11
7 WEN Jang,XIONG Hei-Gang,CHANG Chun-hua (1.Institute of Resources and Environment Science,Xinjiang University;2.Xinjiang Key Laboratory of Oasis Ecology;3.International Research Center for Sustainable Development in Arid and Semi-arid Land,Urumqi 830046,China);The Urbanization Levels of Some Main Cities in Xinjiang and Their Development Countermeasures[J];Journal of Arid Land Resources and Environment;2006-04
8 HE Ling-li1a,b,YUAN Shu-qi1a,b,JI Qing1b(1a.Institute of Tourism Research of Fujian Normal University;1b.School of Geographical Science,Fujian Normal University,Fuzhou 350007,China);Comparison of BP and AHP Method for Tourism Resources Comprehensive Evaluation -taking FuZhou Jinan District as an Example[J];Tourism Forum;2009-06
9 ZHANG Cui-ping,LI Duwu,HU Shan-ju The Faculty of Arts and Social Science,Weifang Medical School,Shandong province,261053 China;The study of nurses' performance appraisal indictors system[J];Chinese Nursing Management;2010-11
10 WANG Dan et al(College of Resources and Environment,Chengdu University of Information Technology,Chengdu,Sichuan 610225);A Review about the Research on Evaluation of Land Resource Sustainable Utilization[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2011-16
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 3 Hits
1 WU Xun, YANG Fan, MI Hong, XI Bin (Center for Population Resource Environment & GIS of XiaMen University, Fujian Xiamen 361005,China);The Research of a Quantitative Evaluation Model of National Economic Mobilization Based on the Analysis Hierarchy Process[A];[C];2006
2 Junjing Yuan, Hongwen Li* College of Engineering, China Agricultural University, Beijing, China, 100083;;APPLICATION OF PROJECTION PURSUIT MODEL IN SOIL EVALUATION OF CONSERVATION TILLAGE[A];[C];2008
3 WANG Qi1, REN Yao-peng2 Department of Computer Science Technology ,YunCheng University,YunCheng,China;Research on the quantifying and calculating model of the software component reusability[A];[C];2010
【Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 CAI Yong hong 1,LIN Chong de 2 (1.Education Department,BNU; 2.Institute of Developmental Psychology,BNU,Beijing 100875,China);The Status of and Reflection on Performance Appraisal Research[J];Journal of Beijing Normal University(Social Science Edition);2001-04
2 FANG Chuang lin 1, MAO Han ying 2 (1 Department of Urban and Environmental Studies, Peking University, Beijing 100871; 2 Institute of Geography, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101);A System of Indicators for Regional Development Planning[J];ACTA GEOGRAPHICA SINICA;1999-05
3 WANG Jing,ZHANG Jin-suo (School of Management,Tianjin University,Tianjin 300072,China;Sc hool of Management,Hebei University of Technology, Tianjin 300130,China );Comparing Several Methods of Assuring Weight Vector in Synthetical Evaluation[J];Journal of Hebei University of Technology;2001-02
4 Wang Yingming (Department of System Science,Xiamen University);An Overview of Priority Methods of Comparison Matrix[J];JOURNAL OF DECISION AND DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS;1995-03
5 Huang Wei Zhong;AHP Method on the Weight of Entropy And It's Application in Ship investment Decision Making[J];JOURNAL OF SHANGHAI MARITIME UNIVERSITY;2000-01
6 Xiong Rui Cao Kunsheng (Nanjing Aeronautical Institute);Hierarchical Analysis of Multiple Criteria Decision Making[J];Systems Engineering-theory & Practice;1992-06
7 WEI Cui\|ping, ZHANG Zhi\|min (Institute of Operations Research, Qufu Normal University, Qufu 273165);An Algorithm to Improve the Consistency of a Comparison Matrix[J];SYSTEMS ENGINEERING-THEORY & PRACTICE;2000-08
8 ZHANG Yong\|hui, LIN Yan, JI Zhuo\|shang (Ship CAD Eng Cent, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, China);Multi-objects Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation of Sea-going Cargo Ship by AHP[J];Systems Engineering-theory & Practice;2002-11
9 Wu Dianting (Department of Resources and Environment Science, Beijing Normal University,100875) Zhang Fengtong Sun Zhanfen Zeng Lina (Geological Company of Building Materials and Nonmetal Resources, Jilin Province, Dehui Jilin 130300);Some Questions on Developing Nonmetal Resources in Jilin Province[J];SYSTEMS ENGINEERING ---THEORY & PRACTICE;1997-05
10 Xu Zeshui (Institute of Communications Engineering, Nanjing 210016);A New Scale Method in Analytic Hierarchy Process[J];SYSTEMS ENGINEERING-THEORY & PRACTICE;1998-10
【Co-citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 WANG Chuan-yu (Dept.of Appl.Math.Phy.,Anhui Institute Mechanical and Electrical Engineering,Wuhu 241000,China);A new method improving the consisten cy of the comparison matrix in AHP[J];Journal of Anhui Institute of Mechanical and Electrical Engineering;2001-04
2 WANG Chuan-yu (Dept.of Appl.Math.Phy.,Anhui University of Technology and Science, Wuhu 241000, China);An algorithm improving the consistency of a comparison matrix[J];Journal of Anhui University of Technology and Science;2004-03
3 ZHAO Xin-yu (Nanchang Institute of Technology,Nanchang,Jiangxi 330099);Study on the Later-evaluation of Water-saving Improvement Project in Irrigation Areas Based on Entropy Method[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2010-02
4 ZHAO De-yi et al(Shijiazhuang University of Economics,Shijiazhuang,Hebei 050031);Sustainable Land-use Evaluation in Counties Based on Entropy Method[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2010-26
5 GUO Shu-hong, ZHANG Jiang-shan(Institute of Environment Science, Fujian Normal University, Fuzhou 350007, China);On the application of intimate data method based on entropy authority to the surface water environmental quality evaluation[J];Journal of Safety and Environment;2007-03
6 YANG Ming (College of Resource Environment and Tourism,Anyang Normal University,Anyang 455002,China);Economic Characteristics and Countermeasures of Underdeveloped Areas in Henan[J];Journal of Anyang Normal University;2008-05
7 Yin Feng,Wu Buxu,Yu Youshan,Ai Dewu (Engineering Institute of the Engineering Corps,PLA Univ.of Sci.and Tech.,Nanjing 210007,China);Valuation Studying about Influencing Factors of Urban Air-Defence Engineering Planning[J];Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering;2010-04
8 SHAO Jie, CAO Yan-ping, SHANG Yu-jin (Brigade of Postgraduate, Bengbu Tank Institute of PLA, Bengbu 233050, China);Evaluation of Armored Mechanization Forces Command Stability Based on Gray Matter Element Analysis Method[J];Ordnance Industry Automation;2009-09
9 Wang Lizhi; Han Furong(Department of Management, Beijing Polytechnic University, 100022);The Application of Mathematical Model in the Comprehensive Evaluation System[J];JOURNAL OF BEIJING POLYTECHNIC UNIVERSITY;1995-04
10 WEI Chun-rong~(1,2),GUO Ying-xia~2,SUN Jian-hua~2,ZHANG Jin-peng~2, LI Ding-qi~2(1.Harbin Institute of Technology School of Astronautics,Harbin 150027,China;2.Department of Safety Engineering,Heilongjiang Institute of Science & Technology,Harbin 150027,China);Improvement in the Safety Check Table Appraisal Based on the Gray Relational Grade[J];Journal of Beijing Union University(Natural Sciences);2009-02
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 XU Zeshui(Institute of Sciences, PLA University of Science and Technology, Nanjing, 210016);The Least Included Angle Method for Priorities of Complementary Judgement Matrices[A];[C];2001
2 Li Jiqian~1 Su Xing~1 Huang Qicheng~1 Wei Cuiping~1 School of Operational Research and Management,Qufu Normal University,Rizhao 276800,China.;Methods of Ranking and Improving the Consistency of Interval Judgment Matrix[A];[C];2007
3 Fan Jie, Xiang Wei (Institute of Geographical Sciences and Resource Research, CAS, Beijing 100101,China);Theory of Location, Spatial Structure and Regional (Spatial) Plan[A];[C];2005
4 LV Yue-jin,ZHAN Ji-zhou,WU Xiao-huan College of Mathematics and Information Science, Guangxi University,Nanning 530004,China.;Method for improving consistency of judgment matrix based on exponential scale[A];[C];2005
5 GONG Yan-de,ZENG Xue-lan,JI Jian-hua College of Mathematics and Information Science,Guangxi University,Nanning 530004,China.;Methods for identifying and improving the consistency of fuzzy judgment matrix[A];[C];2005
6 Zhang Xiangyun~1 Zhao Huaici~2 (1 Shenyang Institute of Automation,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shenyang 110016,China;2 Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100049,China);Application research of AHP method in SAR ships selection[A];[C];2007
7 Yang Shuping Li Mengwei(North China Institute of Technology, Taiyuan 030051);Study on a Grey Classification Priority Method[A];[C];2001
8 Lu Yuejin(Dept of mathematics and information science, Guangxi University, Nanning 530004);Research on Appraisement of Scale System in AHP[A];[C];2001
9 Lun Xinyi Bai Ruoyu(Fushun Petroleum, Liaoning Fushun 113001);A New Method for Solving Weigh Vector[A];[C];2001
10 Zhan Jizhou Lu Yuejin Cheng Xianjuan (School of Mathematics and Information Science, Guangxi University, Nanning 530004);Research on Scales in Fuzzy Complement Judgment Matrix[A];[C];2005
【Secondary References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 AN Yun-na et al (College of Geographical Science,Fujian Normal University,Fuzhou,Fujian 350007);Comprehensive Valuation on Soil Nutrient in Dongshan Island of Fujian[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2007-13
2 XUE Bao-shan et al(China University of Geosciences,Wuhan,Hubei 430074);Comparative Study on Models and Methods in the Course of Land Suitability Evaluation[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2009-07
3 WANG Tian-e et al(Information Technology College of Jilin Agricultural University,Changchun,Jilin 130118);Sorting of Judgment Matrix in Uncertain AHP by Maximum Likelihood Method[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2009-33
4 WANG Kun et al (College of Chemistry and Environmental Engineering,Hubei University for Nationalities,Enshi,Hubei 445000);Soil Quality Assessment of the Planting Base of Amorphophallus Konjac in Enshi Prefecture Based on the Analytic Hierarchy Process[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2010-28
5 WU Chun-min et al(College of Trade and Public Administration,Chongqing University,Chongqing 400030);Research on Urban Rural Input-output Difference Based on Improved Topsis Method[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2011-08
6 LIU Lu et al(China University of Geosiciences,Beijing 100083);Study on the Geo-Park Planning Based on Land Coordination[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2011-13
7 WANG Wei~(1,2),MA Dong-hui~1,SU Jing-yu~1,HAN Yang~2,GUO Xiao-dong~1,WANG Zhi-tao~1 (1.Institute of Earthquake Resistance and Disaster Reduction,Beijing University of Technology,Beijing 100124,China; 2.Institute of Engineering Disaster Prevention and Mitigation,Henan University of Technology,Zhengzhou 450052,China);Land Suitability Evaluation of Earthquake Resistance and Hazardous Prevention Planning Based on Niche Construction[J];Journal of Beijing University of Technology;2009-03
8 ZHANG Yansheng1,HUANG Kaoli2,CHEN Jianhui1(1.Dept.of Missile Engineering Ordnance Engineering College,Shijiazhuang 050003,China;2.Ordnance Engineering Institute,Shijiazhuang 050003,China);Testability Optimization Allocation Method Based on Genetic Algorithm[J];Journal of Test and Measurement Technology;2011-02
9 ZHANG Jian-chun1,CHU Shao-lin2,CHEN Quan-gong2(1.College of Grassland Science,Gansu Agriculture University,Lanzhou 730070,China;2.College of Pastoral Agriculture Science and Technology,University,Lanzhou 730020,China);Advances in defining the boundary of farming-grazing transition zone in China[J];Pratacultural Science;2008-03
10 HAN Jiang-tao, GONG Xin-shu (School of Shihezi University,Shihezi Xinjiang 832003,China);The Urbanization Level of Xinjiang Evaluation Based on Indicator System[J];Science Technology and Industry;2010-03
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 3 Hits
1 Zhao Hong-bin Hui Xiang-feng Fu Cheng-bo ( Center for Performance Evaluation of Education Finance SUFE, Shanghai 200433);A Research on the Present Situation of Performance-Related Pay for Compulsory Education Teachers in China——Based on a Study of 25 Provinces,77 Counties and 279 Schools[A];[C];2010
2 Huang Dingxi Chen Yong Li Yun Yan Mingkun;Achieving Compact City Development Through Planning Oriented Land Banking Mechanism[A];[C];2008
3 Chunyou LI Guangxi University of Finance and Economics, Nanning, Guangxi, China;Development of the Tender Evaluation System Based on Department Performance[A];[C];2010
【Secondary Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 Wu Dianting(Department of Geography,Northeast Normal University Changchun, 130024);A PRELIMINARY STUAY ON REGINOAL DEVELOPMENT DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM YANBIAN REGIONAL[J];Scientia Geographica Sinica;1994-03
2 Mao Hanying,,Fang Chuanglin (Institute of Geography, Chinese Academy of Sciences and the State Planning Commission of P.R.China, Beijing,100101) );THE BASIC THOUGHT OF REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN IN NEW PERIOD AND ITS IMPROVING WAY[J];Acta Geographica Sinica;1997-01
3 Mao Hanying(Institute of Geography, Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100101);THE RESEARCH ABOUT AN INDICATOR SYSTEM OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN SHANDONG PROVINCE[J];GEOGRAPHICAL RESEARCH;1996-04
4 Lu Zhonghua;A Study of Structuring Method of Judgement Matrix in Hierarchical Analysis[J];Systems Engineering;1990-01
5 Gong Shiliang;A Study on Shanghai Land Subsidence by the Analytic Hierarchy Process[J];Systems Engineering;1996-03
6 WANG Neng min,SUN Lin yan,WANG Ying luo (School of Management School,Xi′an Jiaotong University,Xian 710049,China);Choosing of Supplier for Green Manufacturing[J];Systems Engineering;2001-02
7 Wang Yingming Fu Guowei (Department of Environmental Engineering, Tsinghua University);A NEW POINT—TO—PLANE DISTANCE PRIORITY METHOD OF COMPARISON MATRIX[J];Journal of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management;1993-04
8 Chen Baoqian Li Shubin Liu Guiru Chai Qiaozhu (Nankai University);AN EIGENVALUE PROBLEM OF A POSITIVE RECIPROCAL MATRIX[J];Applied Mathematics A Journal of Chinese Universities;1991-01
9 Yu Minhua Wu Jianguo (Dept. of Naval and Civil Architecture, East China Shipbuilding Institute, Zhenjiang, Jiangsu, 212003) Xu Changwen (College of Structural Engineering, Tongji University, Shanghai, 200433);Application Advances of Fuzzy Analysis and Design in Shipbuilding Engineering[J];Journal of East China Shipbuilding Institute;1999-01
10 Wang Yingming (Department of System Science,Xiamen University);An Overview of Priority Methods of Comparison Matrix[J];JOURNAL OF DECISION AND DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEMS;1995-03
©2006 Tsinghua Tongfang Knowledge Network Technology Co., Ltd.(Beijing)(TTKN) All rights reserved