Full-Text Search:
Home|Journal Papers|About CNKI|User Service|FAQ|Contact Us|中文
《Progress in Geography》 2012-06
Add to Favorite Get Latest Update

A Literature Review of Progress in Regional Plan Assessment Theory and Methodology

GUO Yao 1,2,CHEN Wen 1(1.Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology,CAS,Nanjing 210008,China;2.Graduate University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100049,China)  
Regional planning has been increasingly regarded as an important way to manage regional resources and coordinate regional development.Practically,regional planning is in face of severe challenges in its implementation stage.Plans are always revised or even collapsed during the actual implementation process.Presently the work of planning is attracting more and more concerns,as well as criticisms.One of the reasons that planning fails in implementation lies in the reason that planning is,by nature,a long-term procedure,which involves a lot of uncertainties.Plans should be evaluated according to the real situation to generate feedbacks and carry out necessary adjustments,so that plans could achieve their best efficiency.Therefore,evaluation is considered as an indispensable process that can ensure the plans will be implemented successfully.Evaluation is not only necessary for building up and stabilizing the social status of regional planning,bu also helpful for understanding the defects and the failure of plans so that evaluation would practically promote the progress of planning in the future.However,research and application of evaluation falls behind regional planning presently.This paper,by reviewing a large amount of past literatures,advocates that the evaluation of regional planning is experiencing the shift from "planning outcome as blueprint" to "the process of planning decision and implementation".The paper also summaried the most popular evaluation methods and issues affecting plan implementation based on the evolution of evaluation theories,and proposed ideas for future studies.
【Fund】: 中国科学院知识创新工程重要方向项目(KZCY2-YW-339-2)
【CateGory Index】: TU982
Download(CAJ format) Download(PDF format)
CAJViewer7.0 supports all the CNKI file formats; AdobeReader only supports the PDF format.
【Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 6 Hits
1 SHI Yuan ZHOU Liya;THEORY,METHOD AND FRAMEWORK OF PLANNING EVALUATION:A CASE STUDY OF SHENZHEN IMMEDIATE PLANNING[J];City Planning Review;2008-06
2 By SUN Shiwen & WANG Fuhai;Urban Public Policy and Urban Planning Policy[J];Urban Planning Forum;2000-06
3 SUN Shiwen,ZHOU Yu;Evaluation Research on Urban Planning Implementation[J];Urban Planning Forum;2003-02
4 LONG Ying1,2,HAN Haoying3,GU Yizhen4,SHEN Zhengjiang5,MAO Qizhi1(1.School of Architecture,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084,China;2.Beijing Institute of Architectural Design,Beijing 100045,China;3.College of Public Administration,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310029,China;4.Department of Urban and Regional Planning,University of California at Berkeley,Berkeley,CA 94720,USA;5.School of Environment Design,Kanazawa University,Kanazawa 920-1192,Japan);Spatio-temporal Evaluation of Urban Planning Implementation[J];Progress in Geography;2011-08
5 SUN Shi-wen;Contradictions of Preparation of City Plan and Its Management of Implementation[J];Planners;2001-03
6 Song Yan,Jiang Zhiyong,Yang Xiaochun,Chen Yanping;Urban Plan Evaluation: Learning from American Examples[J];Planners;2010-03
【Co-citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 Chen Xiaohong,Zhang Hua;Objective Framework and Dynamic Paradigm of Comprehensive Transportation Plan Evaluation in Large Cities[J];Shanghai Urban Management;2010-06
2 HE Hao,SHI Xue-yi(College of Land Science and Technology,China University of Geosciences,Beijing 100083,China);Method for evaluation of implementation effectiveness of comprehensive land use planning in Jincheng[J];Science of Surveying and Mapping;2011-03
3 JIANG Xiu-Juan,ZHAO Shu-Ling (Zhengzhou Institute of Aeronautical Industry Management,Zhengzhou 450015,China);On impact of urban planning upon urban culture[J];Journal of Henan University of Urban Construction;2009-06
4 HE Jia1,BAO Cun-kuan1,XIE Jing2,SHU Ting-fei3,JIANG Da-he1(1.College of Environmental Science and Engineering,State Key Laborato ry of Pollution Control and Resources Reuse,UNEP-Tongji Institute of Environm ent for Sustainable Developmemt,Shanghai 200092,China;2.Taicang Environmenta l Protection Bureau,Taicang 215400,China;3.Management Commission of Kang Qi ao Industrial Park,Shanghai 200022,China);ON EVALUATION INDEX SYSTEM FOR EFFECTIVENESS OF ECOLOGICAL PLAN WITH CASE OF TAICANG ECO-CITY PLAN[J];Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin;2010-09
5 CHEN Jing-qin1,2,CHEN Wen1,SUN Wei1,WU Qing-hua1,2(1.Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008,China; 2.Graduate University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100049,China);RATIONAL AND COORDINATION EVALUATION OF LAND USE IN PLANNING BASED ON REGIONALIZATION OF REGIONAL POTENTIAL DEVELOPMENT——A CASE STUDY OF WUXI CITY[J];Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin;2011-07
6 YANG Shan1,2,ZHANG Wu-gen1,LI Rong-jun2(1.School of Geographical Sciences,Nanjing Normal University,Nanjing 210046,China; 2.Ocean and Islands Management Office,Ocean and Fishery Bureau of Jiangsu Province,Nanjing 210003,China);INDEX SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR IMPLEMENTATION EVALUATION OF MARINE FUNCTIONAL ZONING IN JIANGSU PROVINCE[J];Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin;2011-10
7 YUAN Li-li HUANG Lü-yun;Analyses of the driving mechanism of the evolvement of urban land spatial structure[J];Urban Studies;2005-01
8 KONG Xianfa;Thoughts on the prospectiveness of local development and urban planning profession in the healthy city movement[J];Urban Studies;2005-02
9 WU Jia ZHANG Jingxiang;A research to China's urban planning transition from the view of transforming of the governance[J];Urban Studies;2006-02
10 LIU Jiafu,XING Haifeng,ZHANG jian;Under Market Economy Conditions the Urban-rural Planning and Management of Provincial Domain Facing Questions and the Institutional Innovation[J];Urban Studies;2008-06
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 He Yufan;The Urban Plan Targetting on the Mediation of Multi-interest Groups:case study on the planning process of the Zhangjiabang River green wedge,Shanghai[A];[C];2011
2 Xing Jialin Liu Qinghao;Observations On The management Of Distance Between Living Building in Nanjing[A];[C];2011
3 Yuanlue Fu ( Center for Accounting studies of Xiamen University, P.R. China);The Development and Innovation of Management Control System:Extending Shift-group Accounting to Integrating Corporate Governance[A];[C];2008
4 Yuanlue Fu Center for Accounting Studies of Xiamen University,Xiamen,Fujian,China 361005;The Development and Innovation of Management Control System:Extending General Accounting Control to Integrating Corporate Governance[A];[C];2010
5 YANG Ming (Guangzhou Urban Planning & Research Center,Guangzhou,510030);DISCUSSION ON TOURIST RESORT PLANNING FROM AN ECOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE:STUDY ON GUANGZHOU HOT SPRING RECREATION RESORT[A];[C];2012
6 ;城市规划实施评价机制初探[A];[C];2006
7 ;追寻市场经济下城市规划价值的复归——对新版《城市规划编制办法》的若干解读[A];[C];2006
8 WEI Lihua1 LIU Yuting1 LUO Yan21School of Architecture, State Key Laboratory of Subtropical Building Science, South China Universityof Technology, Guangzhou, 5106412China Academy of Urban & Design, Shenzhen Branch; Shenzhen, 518034;“Implementation Block” of Urban and Rural Planning and Planning Inspectorate[A];[C];2008
9 ;Research on Guarantee mechanism of Urban Planning Implementation[A];[C];2008
10 ;Evaluation Model and Method of Urban System Planning,the Case of Bengbu[A];[C];2012
【Co-references】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 9 Hits
1 CHEN Yu-xian et al(School of Geographic and Biologic Sciences,Guizhou Normal University,Guiyang,Guizhou 550001);Study on the Post-evaluation of Environmental Planning Based on Logical Framework Approach[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2011-15
2 Pei Hongping,Wang Yong (Department of Environmental Science, Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310028);Approach on Developmental Tendency of China Environmental Planning[J];Chongqing Environmental Science;2003-02
3 ;Study on Index System of Yunnan Environmental Performance Assessment[J];Environmental Protection;2006-02
4 ①② Cao Dong;① Song Cunyi;②Cao Ying;②Cao Guozhi;③Li Wanxin(①Beijing University of Science and Technology,Beijing 100083,China;②Academy of Environmental Planning of China,Beijing 100012,China;③Tingshua University,Beijing 100084,China);Overseas Experience about Environmental Performance Assessment and Inspiration for China[J];Value Engineering;2008-10
5 CAO Shu-Yan,XIE Gao-DiInstitute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research,CAS,Beijing 100101,China;Applying input-output analysis for calculation of ecological footprint of China[J];Acta Ecologica Sinica;2007-04
6 LUO Shi-peng1,ZHANG Song2(1.School of Civil Engineering & Architecture,Wuhan University of Technology,Wuhan 430070,China; 2.Yangtze River Scientific Research Institute,Wuhan 430000,China);Applying Logical Framework Approach in Hydropower Construction Project Social Impacts Post-project Assessment[J];Journal of Wuhan University of Technology;2009-15
7 PENG Guo-fu (College of Management, Xiangtan University, Xiangtan, Hunan 411105, China);Retrospection on Several Basic Questions of Govermment Performance Appraise[J];;2004-03
8 LONG Feng GAO Shu-ting Ge Cha-zhong WANG Jin-nan YANG Qi-jia (Chinese Academy for Environmental Planning,Beijing 100012,China);Assessment of Water Sewage Charge Policy Based On the Logical Framework Approach[J];China Population,Resources and Environment;2011-S2
9 SUN Rui-lin,LUO Feng(Hubei Environment Science Research Academy,Wuhan Hubei 430072 China);Medium-term Assessment of the 11th-five Years Environmental Protection Planning in Hubei Province[J];Environmental Science Survey;2011-03
【Secondary Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 WANG Fuhai, CHEN Hongjun, ZOU Bing, SHI Yuan;SHORT-TERM CONSTRUCTION PLANNING: FROM AFTER DINNER DESERT TO MAIN DISHESSOME LESSONS FROM REVIEWING THE MASTER PLAN OF SHENZHEN[J];City Planning Review;2002-12
2 ZOU Bing; QIAN Hanzheng;AN ENVISAGED INTEGRATION OF IMMEDIATE PLAN AND 11TH FIVE-YEAR-PLAN[J];City Planning Review;2005-11
3 LU Xiaobei; WU Wei;ON THE EVALUATION OF URBAN PLAN IMPLE-MENTATION[J];City Planning Review;2006-11
4 LONG Ying; HE Yong; LIU Xin;DU Liqun;PLANNING OF THE CONTROLLED-CONSTRUCTION AREA IN BEIJING:ESTABLISHING URBAN EXPANSION BOUNDARY[J];City Planning Review;2006-12
5 OUYANG Peng;URBAN PLANNING EVALUATION MODEL AND METHOD IN THE PERSPECTIVE OF PUBLIC POLICY[J];City Planning Review;2008-12
6 SUN Shiwen,ZHOU Yu;Evaluation Research on Urban Planning Implementation[J];Urban Planning Forum;2003-02
7 TIAN Li,LV Chuanting,SHEN Tiyan;Theoretical and Empirical Research on Implementation Evaluation of City Master Plan:A Case of Guangzhou City Master Plan(2001-2010)[J];Urban Planning Forum;2008-05
8 LONG Ying1, 2, HAN Haoying3, MAO Qizhi1 (1. School of Architecture, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China; 2. Beijing Institute of City Planning, Beijing 100045, China; 3. College of Public Administration, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310029, China);Establishing Urban Growth Boundaries Using Constrained CA[J];Acta Geographica Sinica;2009-08
9 LONG Ying1,2,SHEN Zhenjiang3,MAO Qizhi1,DANG Anrong1 (1.School of Architecture,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084,China;2.Beijing Institute of City Planning,Beijing 100045,China;3.School of Environment Design,Kanazawa University,Kanazawa 920-1192,Japan);Form Scenario Analysis Using Constrained Cellular Automata[J];Acta Geographica Sinica;2010-06
10 LIU Xuhua1,2, WANG Jinfeng1, LIU Mingliang4,1 & MENG Bin1,2,3 1. Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100101, China; 2. Graduate School of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100039, China; 3. College of Arts and Sciences of Beijing Union University, Beijing 100083, China; 4. School of Forestry and Wildlife Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, Alabama, AL36849, USA;Spatial heterogeneity of the driving forces of cropland change in China[J];中国科学(D辑:地球科学)(英文版);2005-12
©2006 Tsinghua Tongfang Knowledge Network Technology Co., Ltd.(Beijing)(TTKN) All rights reserved