Full-Text Search:
Home|Journal Papers|About CNKI|User Service|FAQ|Contact Us|中文
《Science Research Management》 2010-04
Add to Favorite Get Latest Update

Study on the approach to optimize the indicator system of science research evaluation:A case study of the scientific and technological innovation competitiveness evaluation of Chinese universities

Ding Jingda,Qiu Junping (Research Center for Chinese Science Evaluation,Wuhan University,Wuhan 430072,China)  
Taking the case of the indicator system for scientific and technological innovation competitiveness evaluation of Chinese universities that the research center for Chinese science evaluation of Wuhan University designed as an example,a kind of optimization idea and method for the indicator system,especially the weights are brought forward by using the indicator data in the last three years,and further tests indicate that it was scientific and reasonable. It is believed that this kind of optimization idea and method not only is adaptable to the field of science research evaluation,but also has a positive significance and reference value for the optimization of evaluating indicator system in other areas.
【CateGory Index】: G644
Download(CAJ format) Download(PDF format)
CAJViewer7.0 supports all the CNKI file formats; AdobeReader only supports the PDF format.
【References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 Ai Chunyan;Zhao Fei;You Yue;Liu Suqing;;Evaluation Methods of Scientific Research Competitiveness[J];Journal of Academic Libraries;2013-05
2 Zhao Fei;Ai Chunyan;You Yue;Liu Suqing;;Bibliometric Evaluation of University Scientific Research——A Case Study of Peking University[J];Journal of Academic Libraries;2014-01
3 LU Liping;JIAO Keyan;;Study on District Differentiation of Science and Technology Innovation in Henan Province[J];Urban Development Studies;2014-07
4 Zhang Biansheng;Henan Province Institute of S&T Development Strategy;;Current Situation Analysis of the Regional Scientific and Technological Innovation Construction in China[J];Innovation Science and Technology;2015-01
5 CHEN Jie-xiu;MA Chun-mei;ZHU Jun-wen;Graduate School of Education,Shanghai Jiao Tong University;;The Purpose, Methods and Operational Mechanism of Excellence in Research for Australia[J];Fudan Education Forum;2015-02
6 CHEN Guang-yu;WANG Wei-xian;ZHENG Shu-yang;SHAO Yun-fei;University of Electronic Science and Technology of China;;Evaluation and Decision Method for Enterprise Technology Innovation Project Efficiency Index Based on TRIZ and DEA[J];Journal of University of Electronic Science and Technology of China(Social Sciences Edition);2015-05
7 NIU Yanmei,WU Wenqing,JIA Suotang(Research Center for the Ministry of Education and the Provincial MinistryCosponsoring Affairs,Shanxi University,Taiyuan 030006,China);On Performance Evaluation Indicator System of Discipline Under New Discipline Directory[J];Journal of North University of China(Social Science Edition);2012-01
8 CAO Xing, SHE Gen-fei;Study on Profit Distribution Model and Proportion of University Technology Innovation and Technology Entrepreneurship Decision-making[J];Scientific Decision Making;2012-04
9 ZHU Jianyu1,ZHAO Hongjun2,FANG Xi1(1.Shanghai Institute of Technology,Shanghai 201418,China 2.Shanghai Institute of Foreign Trade,Shanghai 201620,China);Empirical Study on Model Comparison of Evaluation of Scientific Research Efficiency Performance and Innovation Capability of Universities[J];Science and Technology Management Research;2012-17
10 Yang Chuanxi1,2,Xu Wanqiang2,Zhang Junbiao3(1.School of Public Administration,Huazhong University of Science and Technology,Wuhan 430074,China; 2.School of Management,Guilin University of Technology,Guilin 541004,China; 3.College of Economics and Management,Huazhong Agricultural University,Wuhan 430070,China);The allocation efficiency of S&T resources at agricultural and forestry universities[J];Science Research Management;2013-04
【Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 7 Hits
1 Mao Baohua;Analysis to Evaluation Index with the Determination of Their Weights[J];Systems Engineering;1991-04
2 Liu Li liHebei Institute of Architecture and Civil Engineering;The Selective Method of Evaluation Index[J];Journal of Hebei Institute of Architectural Engineering;2004-01
3 (Department of Environmental Sciences of Shanxi University,Taiyuan 030006)(Institute of Environmental Sciences of Beijing Normal University,Beijing 100875);A STUDY ON THE PRINCIPLE AND METHOD OF INSTALLATION OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT INDEX[J];ACTA SCIENTIAE CIRCUMSTANTIAE;1998-05
4 LI Sheng-yang~1, ZHANG Xiao-wu~2, XING Li-ning~3(1. South China University of Technology,Guangzhou Guangdong 510640,China;2. Star Soft Technology Ltd., Beijing 100083,China;3. National University of Defense Technology, Changsha Hunan 410073,China);The Method of Dynamic Selecting Measures Based on Sensitivity Analysis[J];Computer Simulation;2005-03
5 Wang Zongjun,Xu Xing,Xia Tian(School of Management,Huazhong University of Science and Technology,Wuhan 430074,China);R&D personal measurement and evaluation: A literature review[J];Science Research Management;2008-04
6 ZHANG Wei-qun(1.School of Statistics,Tianjin University of Finance and Economics,Tianjin 300222,China; 2.School of Statistics,Xi'an University of Finance and Economics,Xi'an 710061,China);A Study on the Method of Evaluation of Indicators System Construction and Goodness[J];Statistics & Information Forum;2006-06
7 MAO Ding-xiang (School of International Business & Management,Shanghai University, Shanghai 201800,China);A Combinational Evaluation Method Resulting in Consistency between Subjective and Objective Evaluation in the Least Squares Sense[J];Chinese Journal of Management Science;2002-05
【Co-citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 ZHAO Hui (School of Economics and Management,Shandong Agricultural University,Taian,271018,Shandong);A Brief Discussion of the Indicator System of Rural Sustainable Development——Evaluation of for Shandong Province' s Rural Sustainable Development[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural University;2002-03
2 LU Di et al(Department of the Environment and Geography Science,Pingdingshan University,Pingdingshan,Henan 467000);Analysis of the Ecological Efficiency from Human Disturbance in the Process of Land Consolidation[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2008-18
3 CHEN Guo-hua,LIANG Tao,ZHANG Hua-wen(Institute of Safety Science and Engineering,School of Industrial Equipment and Control Engineering,South China University of Technology,Guangzhou 510640,China);Evaluation model for urban-regional disaster-bearing capacity and its application[J];Journal of Safety and Environment;2008-02
4 DAI Ming-xin1,2,HU Yan-di1,PENG Shi-tao1,2,BAI Zhi-peng1,TIAN Yu1,WANG Peng1(1 College of Environmental Science and Engineering,Nankai University,Tianjin 300071,China;2 Laboratory of Environmental Protection in Water Transport Engineering,Tianjin Research Institute for Water Transport Engineering,Ministry of Transport,Tianjin 300456,China);The application of AHP-Fuzzy approach to the sea-port environmental carrying capacity evaluation[J];Journal of Safety and Environment;2008-05
5 Liu Jianlin1,Xie Jiancang1,Ma Bin1,Kong Ke2(1.Xi'an University of Technology,Xi'an 710048,China;2.Jinan University,Jinan 250022,China);Comprehensive Evaluation for Water Use Systems with AHP-MF Model[J];Environmental Science and Management;2007-02
6 Wu Mingqun1,2,An Yanling1,2,Zhou Xide3,Xiao Ying4(1.College of Resources and Environmental Engineering,Guizhou University,Guiyang 550003,China; 2.Kay Laboratory of Karst Environment and Geohazard Prevention of Guizhou University, Ministry of Education,Guiyang 550003,China; 3.Mining College of,Guizhou University,Guiyang 550003,China; 4.Guiyang Huayida Trade Co.Ltd,Guiyang 550001,China);Establishment of the Index System of Cleaner Production Assessment of Phosplate Mines——Phosplate Mines of Guiyang A Case Study[J];Environmental Science and Management;2009-02
7 YANG Chong-lin1,WEN Xian-ming2(1.Department of Economy,Capital Normal University,Beijing 100089;2.School of Economy,Changsha University of Science and Technology,Changsha 410076,China);A Historical Change from Traditional GDP to Sustainable Development GDP:Significance of Sustainable Development GDP Research to China[J];Journal of Beijing Normal University(Social Sciences);2008-01
8 YU Liping,PAN Yuntao,WU Yishan address Institute of Scientific & Technical Information of China,100038,Beijing,China;Research on the construction of academic journal evaluation system and related issues[J];Acta Editologica;2009-03
9 Yu Liping Pan Yuntao Wu Yishan(Institute of Scientific & Technical Information of China,Beijing,100038);Research on Combined Assessing for Academic Periodical Based on Extreme Value Method[J];Library and Information;2009-04
10 LI Na(Institute of Management,ChangchunUniversity,Changchun 130012,China);Research of fuzzy analogical analytical evaluation methods for construction contracted projects[J];Journal of Changchun Institute of Technology(Natural Sciences Edition);2009-03
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 BAI Shizhen 1,2,XIA Shengsheng 1 1.Academy School of Management,Harbin University of Commerce,Harbin 150028,P.R.China2.Research Center of Modern Logistics,Harbin University of Commerce,Harbin 150028,P.R.China;Evaluation for Complex System of Supply Chain Trust Based on Combination Method[A];[C];2010
2 LI Qian-mu1,2, QI Yong2, HOU Jun2 (1. Department of Science and Technology Management, Nanjing University of Sci.&Tech., Nanjing, 210094; 2. State Key Lab of Computer Software and New Technology, Nanjing University, Nanjing, 210093; 3.Department of Computer Science and Technology, Nanjing University of Sci.&Tech., Nanjing, 210094);A New University Scientific Research Competitiveness Evaluation[A];[C];2006
3 ;Inter-Provincial Comparison Research on Science and Technology Innovation Ability of High Education Institute of China[A];[C];2008
4 LI Mei-juan, CHEN Guo-hong,LIN Yuan-qing Management School,Fuzhou University, Fuzhou 350002,China.;Study on drift—based combination evaluation method[A];[C];2005
5 Shi Jiansheng(Institute of Hydrogeolagy and Engineering Geology, CAGS, Shijiazhuang);China Frail Geo-ecozone Classification and Framework Characteristics[A];[C];1999
6 Gao Yang Fei Chengliang ( College of Management ,Central South University ,Changsha hunan 410083 China);An Objective Combined Evaluation Based On Distance Entropy and Relative Entropy[A];[C];2008
7 Gao Yang Fei Chengliang ( College of Management ,Central South University ,Changsha hunan 410083China);An Objective Combined Evaluation Based On Whole Diversity and Cooperative Games[A];[C];2008
8 ;上市公司财务绩效评价有效性实证研究[A];[C];2008
9 ZENG Rong,WEI Yi-ming,FAN Ying,LI Zhi-jie(Institute of Policy and Management,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100080,China);Analysis and Assessment Indicator System For Harmonization Development Among Population,Resource,Environment and Economy[A];[C];2000
10 LI Mei-juan~1 CHEN Guo-hong~1 CHEN Yan-tai~2 CAI Bin-qing~1 (1.Management School,Fuzhou University,Fuzhou 350002,China;2.Management School,Fudan University,Shanghai 200433,China);Study on Combination Evaluation Method Based on Rough Set[A];[C];2005
【Co-references】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 TIAN Fei(Department of Sociology,Anhui University,Hefei,Anhui,230039);The Construction of Social Indicator System with Structure Equation Modeling Technology[J];Journal of Anhui University(Philosophy & Social Sciences);2007-06
2 ZHU Wen-zao (Dept. of Sci. & Tech. , Anhui University of Science and Technology, Wuhu 241000);The establishment of systematized evaluation indexes to university scientific research capacity[J];Journal of Anhui University of Technology and Science;2003-03
3 NING Xiao-li(Baotou Teachers College,Inner Mongolia University of Science and Technology,Baotou,Inner Mongolia 014030);Construction of Urban Ecological Environmental Quality Evaluation Index System in Baotou City Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2010-04
4 WANG Ying,LIU Yan-ping (School of Economics and Management,Beijing Jiaotong University,Beijing 100044,China);Study on the Evaluation of Eight Management Colleges' Efficiency of Scientific Research Based on Data Envelopment Analysis[J];Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University(Social Sciences Edition);2007-04
5 Zhu Yin Meng Zhiyong Kan Shuyu (College of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Northern Jiaotong University,Beijing 100044);Determination of Weight Value by AHP[J];JOURNAL OF NORTHERN JIAOTONG UNIVERSITY;1999-05
6 CHEN Liang-you, HAN Xin-wei (School of Economics and Management, Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Beijing 100083,China);Some Viewpoints of Tendency and Characteristics of Future Scien-tech Innovation[J];Journal of Beijing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics(Social Sciences Edition);2002-03
7 LU Ping, WU Bin( 1. College of Computer Science, Beijing Polytechnic University, Beijing 100022, China; 2. "211" Office of Beijing Polytechnic University, Beijing 100022, China );Application of AHP in the Sci & Tech Assessment System of Colleges and Universities[J];Journal of Beijing Polytechnic University;2002-03
8 LIU Lin-qing,SHI Guan-qun,CHEN Xiao-xia;A Study on the Entrepreneurship Ecosystem of MIT[J];Comparative Education Review;2009-07
9 Mi feng; Li Jiyue; Yang Jiawei. School of Resources and Environment, Beijing For. Univ., 100083, P. R.China.;Review on research of evaluation on forest ecological benefits.[J];Journal of Beijing Forestry University;2003-06
10 He Xuefeng, Peng Chaoqun Editorial Office of the Chinese Journal of Nonferrous Metals, Central South University, 410083, Changsha, China;Dynamic evaluation model of academic influence of sci-tech periodicals[J];Acta Editologica;2002-04
【Secondary References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 CHEN Hong;School of Economic and Management,Northeast Forestry University;;Study on the Efficiency of Science and Technology Resource Allocation in Agriculture and Forestry University in China[J];Journal of Anhui Agricultural Sciences;2014-20
2 ZHANG Hong-lin;ZHANG Xiao-qun;DENG Wei;CAO Miao;OU-YANG Hai-ying;YAN Xue;Yangtze River Fisheries Research Institute Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences;Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences;;Analysis on output of academic papers in Chinese of Yangtze River Fisheries Research Institute[J];Freshwater Fisheries;2014-02
3 ZHANG Bo;YE Xiao;Division of Scientific Research,Beijing Union University;;Study of Scientific Research Evaluation of Application-oriented University[J];Journal of Beijing Union University(Natural Sciences);2015-01
4 FENG Haiyan;Department of Science and Technology,Beijing Jiaotong University;;Analysis of university scientific research team innovation ability level based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method[J];Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University;2014-06
5 Li Feng;;How to Carry out Discipline Competitiveness of Library Subject Service——Inspiration from the "International Comparative Performance of the UKResearch Base" report[J];Journal of Academic Libraries;2015-02
6 YOU Guang-rong;SUN Xiao;WANG Ji-min;SUN Min;State Key Laboratory on Complex Systems Simulation;Department of Information Science,Peking University;;Bibliometric Analysis and Development Proposals on China's System of Systems Engineering Research[J];Journal of China Academy of Electronics and Information Technology;2013-06
7 JIA Gangtao;CHEN Xin;Shaanxi University of Science and Technology;;Reviewed on the Integration of Science and Technology Resources[J];Science and Technology Management Research;2014-09
8 Lin Zhuoling;Huang Ying;He Langping;Office of Science and Technology,South China Normal University;Development and Planning Department,South China Normal University;South China Academy of Advanced Optoelectronics,South China Normal University;;Evaluation on Science and Technology Innovation Efficiency among Different Types of Universities[J];Journal of South China Normal University(Natural Science Edition);2014-04
9 TAO Yun;LI Tie-fan;ZHANG Le-qin;Department of Economics and Trade,Chizhou University;Division of Scientific Research,Chizhou University;Department of Resource Environment and Tourism,Chizhou University;;The Comprehensive Evaluation and Optimization of Science and Technology Innovation Capacity of Universities at Provincial-level—Evidence from Anhui Province[J];East China Economic Management;2014-10
10 YANG Wu;XIE Shiyu;WANG Le;University of Science&Technology Beijing;;The Research on the University Technological Innovation Climate Index Model[J];Science and Technology Management Research;2014-19
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 1 Hits
1 Xue Wang and Yuanming Ding School of Information Engineering, Dalian University Dalian, China;Research of Index Combination Weighting Model on Discipline Evaluation[A];[C];2013
【Secondary Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 LIU Xi xia, GAO Hai yun, WANG Liang xi(Armored Force Engineering College, Beijing 100072, China);An Application of Grey Relational Analysis in Mobility-evaluation of Main Battle Tanks[J];;2000-03
2 CHEN Chun liang LI Jun (Armored Force Engineering College, Beijing 100072, China);The integrated evaluation of the power equipment of armored vehicles[J];Acta Armamentarll The Volume of Tank, Armored Vehicle and Engine;2001-01
3 LU Ping, WU Bin( 1. College of Computer Science, Beijing Polytechnic University, Beijing 100022, China; 2. "211" Office of Beijing Polytechnic University, Beijing 100022, China );Application of AHP in the Sci & Tech Assessment System of Colleges and Universities[J];Journal of Beijing Polytechnic University;2002-03
4 Yuan Rui'e,Hu Anna;Review of the Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) in UK[J];Comparative Education Review;2003-10
5 Wu Qizong Yu Zhonghua (Department of Applied Mathematics);SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS FOR NONLINEAR PROGRAMMING USING GENERALIZED REDUCED GRADIENT METHOD[J];Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology;1989-04
6 ZHU Shun ying\+1,\ WANG\ Hong\+1,\ LI Guan shou\+2 (1 Chongqing Jiaotong University,Chongqing 400074,China;2 Highway Construction and Management Department of Chongqing Traffic Committee,Chongqing 401147,China);The selecting of measures of effectiveness of highway network planning[J];Journal of Chongqing Jiaotong Institute;2002-02
7 Shi Benshan;Yang Jimei;Wu Jingye;Sensitivity Analysis about Appraisal Index Systems[J];Systems Engineering;1990-05
8 Gu Changyao Qiu Wanhua;A CET Method for Multiple Objectives Decision[J];Systems Engineering;1991-02
9 Mao Baohua;Analysis to Evaluation Index with the Determination of Their Weights[J];Systems Engineering;1991-04
10 PAN Mao-yuan & WU Mei (Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, Fujian, China);The Classification and Localization of Higher Education Institutions[J];Fudan Education Forum;2003-03
©2006 Tsinghua Tongfang Knowledge Network Technology Co., Ltd.(Beijing)(TTKN) All rights reserved