Full-Text Search:
Home|Journal Papers|About CNKI|User Service|FAQ|Contact Us|中文
《Chinese Journal of Law》 2006-03
Add to Favorite Get Latest Update

Adjudication According to Legal Principles

Chen Linlin  
The adjudication according to legal principles needs to resolve three problems one by one:how to identify the involved legal principles;how to decide the priority of the application between rules and principles, i. e. in what a case can the judge ignore the rules and make the decision according to princi- ples;how to resolve the conflicts between legal principles, in other words, whether the judge can get the “exclusively right answer”by balancing the related principles. To solve these problems, contemporary theories of judicial decision-making have offered respective answers, but none of them contains reliable operational approaches and instructions. Their failures originate in the essence of adjudication according to principles that when the rules are exhausted, judges will make use of some inherent value judgments of the legal system to offer rationalized reasons for their decisions. Yet once the value judgments enter into the adjudication, the decision will probably become subjective, arbitrary and incomprehensive.
【CateGory Index】: D90
Download(CAJ format) Download(PDF format)
CAJViewer7.0 supports all the CNKI file formats; AdobeReader only supports the PDF format.
【References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 5 Hits
1 LI Wei;On the Certainty of the Judge's Interpretation[J];Science of Law(Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law);2008-02
2 LIU Zhigang;The Public Order and Moral and the Fundamental Rights[J];Science of Law(Journal of Northwest University of Political Science and Law);2009-03
3 HU Jin-guang,Wang Shu-cheng(Law School,Renmin University of China,Beijing 100872,China);An Analysis about Standardization of Relieving Law of Exhausting[J];Journal of Jianghan University(Social Sciences);2008-02
4 ZHANG Hao1,SUN Shu-yun2(1.School of Law,Zhejiang University,Hangzhou 310028,China)(2.School of Law,Shanxi University,Taiyuan 030006,China);Analysis of the Function of Soft Law in the Reform of the Countryside Hospital[J];Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology(Social Sciences Edition);2007-06
5 ZHU Li-jun (Fudan University Law College,Shanghai 200438,China);When Legal Rule Met With Legal Principle——In the Perspective of the Argument on Verdict of Luzhou Bequeathal Case[J];Journal of Inner Mongolia University for Nationalities(Social Sciences);2009-01
【Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 2 Hits
1 Zhang Guoqing;Between Virtues: A Problematic of Isaiah Berlin's Values-Pluralism and Its Criticism[J];Philosophical Researche;2004-07
2 Lin Laifan & Wang Hui;The "Only Right Answer" in Law: About Dworkin's Theory[J];;2004-10
【Co-citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 Li Chenghua(Master student,Constitution and Administrative Law Major,Law School of Nanjing University.,Nanjing,210093,China);Benefit-balance in Utilizing Administrative Discretional Right[J];Journal of Jiangsu Police Officer College;2006-01
2 LI Ke(Law School,Henan University,Kaifeng 475001,China);The Limitation of Legal Regulations as Laws[J];Journal of China University of Geosciences(Social Sciences Edition);2007-05
3 HE Jin-qian1,ZHOU Xiong-wen2(1.Law School,Hunan University of Science and Technology,Xiangtan 411201,China; 2.Hunan University of Technology,Zhuzhou 412000,China;Study of the Legal Orientation of Chinese Lender of Last Resort[J];Journal of Dalian University;2009-02
4 HU Jin-guang,Wang Shu-cheng(Law School,Renmin University of China,Beijing 100872,China);An Analysis about Standardization of Relieving Law of Exhausting[J];Journal of Jianghan University(Social Sciences);2008-02
5 FANG Gui-rong,LI Chao(Department of Law,Hunan College of Science and Technology,Yongzhou 425100 China);The Discussion of Extending of Modern Good Faith Principle[J];Hebei Law Science;2007-11
6 CHEN Jia,SHAN Dong-liang(College of Politics and Law, Hebei University, Baoding 071002,China);On Judiciary Value of Honesty and Credit[J];Hebei Academic Journal;2006-05
7 ZHANG Chao(Shandong Institute of Business and Technology,Yantai 264005,Shandong,China);The Right to Privacy: Weighting between Legal Interests and Its Justifying in Cases[J];Journal of Jiangsu Radio & Television University;2008-06
8 ZHU Li-jun(Law School of Fudan University,Shanghai 200438,China);Application Rule and Understanding on Article 7 of "General Civil Law"[J];Journal of Henan University of Science & Technology(Social Science);2009-01
9 ZHU Li-jun (Fudan University Law College,Shanghai 200438,China);When Legal Rule Met With Legal Principle——In the Perspective of the Argument on Verdict of Luzhou Bequeathal Case[J];Journal of Inner Mongolia University for Nationalities(Social Sciences);2009-01
10 Song Wei-yan(Wulian Road Sales Department of Shanghai,China Galaxy Securities Co.,Ltd.,Shanghai 200047,China);Talk on the Principle of Good Faith in Security Law[J];Taxation and Economy;2007-03
【Co-references】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 陈金钊;法律解释及其基本特征[J];Law Science (Journal of Northwest Institute of Political Science and Law);2000-06
2 CHEN Jin zhao (Law School, Shandong University, Jinan 250100,China);CHARACTERISTICS OF LAW AND LAW INTERPRETATION ——A Study of the Ontology of Law Interpretation[J];Journal of Guangxi Normal University(Philosophy and Social Science Edition);2003-02
3 Yu Xing-zhong;Natural Law and Law Becoming Sacred and Common Customs[J];Law Science (Journal of Northwest Institute of Political Science and Law);2002-03
4 ;On The Academic Outline Of Legislating 《Contingency Law To Emergencies》[J];Law Science Magazine;2006-04
5 ZHANG Xiao-ming1,2(1 School of Humanities and Social Sciences University of Science and Technology Beijing,Beijing 100083,China;2.School of Public Administration Renmin University of China,Beijing l00872,China);Pre-crisis Risk Management and Its Evaluation[J];Journal of University of Science and Technology Beijing(Social Sciences Edition);2007-01
6 YAO Hui;On Expansion of Sources of Civil Laws[J];Northern Legal Science;2008-01
7 MIAO Lian-ying;The Functions, Principles of Constitutional Interpretation & Its Prospect in China[J];Law Science (Journal of Northwest University of Politics and Law);2004-06
8 ;拯救客观性——关于法治方法的理论探索[J];Law Science (Journal of Northwest Institute of Political Science and Law);2001-06
9 GU Min-gan(The Law School,Southwestern University of Finance and Economics,Chengdu,610072);On The Claim and Its Status in Civil Rights System[J];Contemporary Law Review;2007-04
10 Thang Jie (School of Law, Fudan University,Shanghai 200433);Reconstruction of Law Interpretation System ──On the Current Law Interpretation System of China and Its Perfection[J];Fudan Journal(Social Sciences Edition);2001-06
【Secondary Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 4 Hits
1 Zhang Guo qing (Department of Political Studies and Administration, School of law, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310028);How to Save Others' Enterprise ——A Criticism of Michel Foucault's and Isaiah Berlin's Irrational Philosophies[J];Fudan Journal(Social Sciences Edition);2004-04
2 ;利益的层次结构与利益衡量的展开——兼评加藤一郎的利益衡量论 ?[J];Cass Journal of Law;2002-01
3 Ge Hongyi;Position and Role of Legal Principles in Legal Reasoning[J];Cass Journal of Law;2002-06
4 Zhang Jing;Uncertainty of Land use Rules:An Explanatory Framework[J];Social Sciences In China;2003-01
©2006 Tsinghua Tongfang Knowledge Network Technology Co., Ltd.(Beijing)(TTKN) All rights reserved