Full-Text Search:
Home|Journal Papers|About CNKI|User Service|FAQ|Contact Us|中文
《China Population Resources and Environment》 2010-01
Add to Favorite Get Latest Update

Comparison and Analysis on Different Methods of Sustainability Evaluation at Home and Abroad

HAO Cui LI Hong-yuan MENG Wei-qing(College of Environmental Science and Engineering,Nankai University,Tianjin 300071,China)  
This article introduces history,methodology and application of sustainability evaluation methods such as environmental sustainability index (ESI),ecological footprint (EF),emergy ratios (renewability and emergy sustainability index) (EmPIs) and sustainability evaluation indicators.ESI is suitable for multi-national scale,EF and EmPIs for multi-national,sub-national,regional and local scales,while sustainability evaluation indicators are only for small ecosystems.We also discuss the advantages and disadvantages among these methods:ESI provides us large information,but with complicated calculation process;EF has a simple calculation progress,but lack of some sustainable information such as soil loss and forest destruction;EmPIs considers all the situations which can be very flexible according to specific systems and has a relatively simple calculation process,but its theory is a little difficult for non-ecological researchers to understand;Sustainability evaluation indicators are flexible,but from a subjective view.Analyses above which point out application scale of each method and its abvantoges and disadvantages are useful references to the choosing of suitable sustainability evalution methods choosing evaluation methodologies.
【Fund】: 天津市科技支撑计划重点项目(08ZCGYSF00200)资助
【CateGory Index】: X22
Download(CAJ format) Download(PDF format)
CAJViewer7.0 supports all the CNKI file formats; AdobeReader only supports the PDF format.
【References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 HUANG Xun;HUANG Minsheng;College of Geographical Science,Fujian Normal University;Cultivation Base of State Key Laboratory of Humid Subtropical Mountain Ecology;;Relationship between sustainable urban development and economic growth based on emergy analysis:a case study of Quanzhou City[J];地理科学进展;2015-01
2 FU Rong;ZHANG Lijun;Information Center of Ministry of Land and Resources;;Review on the Evaluation Index System of Eco-Civilization in China[J];国土资源情报;2014-10
3 WANG Cheng-hao;ZHANG Jia-qi;QU Teng;WU Yi-jin;Central China Normal University School of Urban and Environmental Science;Central China Normal University Institute of Sustainable Development;;Study on Sustainable Development of Tourism in Enshi Autonomous Prefecture Based on Ecological Footprint Model[J];资源开发与市场;2014-08
4 YANG Xue-bin;DING Wei;School of Management,University of Fuzhou;;An Empirical Study of Regional Sustainable Development Ability Based on Consistency Combination Evaluation[J];物流工程与管理;2013-10
5 ZHUANG Jia-qiang;School of Public Finance and Taxation,Zhongnan University of Economics and Law;;Provincial Sustainability Development of China: Measurement and Comparison Based on Inclusive Wealth Index[J];中国人口.资源与环境;2013-09
6 WANG Ying;HUANG Maoxing;XU Gang;Faculty of Economics and Commerce.Fujian Jiangxia College;School of Economics of FuJian Normal University;;Economic Analysis of Connotation and Calculation of Environmental Competitiveness[J];成都理工大学学报(社会科学版);2013-05
7 ZHAO Cai-yun,YANG Wen-jie(College of Economics and Management,Northwest A & F University,Yangling 712100,China);Study on sustainable development of northern Shaanxi resource county——A case study of Jingbian county[J];广东农业科学;2013-10
8 HE Yan-xin,LI Jin-hua(School of Resources and Environmental Engineering,Anhui University,Hefei 230601,China);ECOLOGICAL COMPETITIVENESS ESTIMATION BASED ON THE STRATEGY OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT——A CASE STUDY IN ANHUI PROVINCE[J];长江流域资源与环境;2013-04
9 Shang Rui1,Bai Shixiu2,Zhang Jinxia3(1.The Financial Science Institute of Ministry of Finance,Beijing 100142;2.Northeast Forestry University,Harbin Heilongjiang 150040;3.Heilongjiang Institute of Science and Technology,Harbin Heilongjiang 150027);On the Sustenance of Science-environment-technology of Resource-based Area——Taking the Example of Heilongjiang Province[J];东北农业大学学报(社会科学版);2012-03
10 BAN Yuan-chong1,LUO Gao-yuan2,WANG Yuan-yuan3,ZHANG Hong3(1.College of Geography and Environmental Sciences,Zhejiang Normal University,Jinhua 321004,PRC; 2.Zhejiang Vocational College of Commerce,Hangzhou 31005,PRC; 3.School of Earth Sciences,China University of Geosciences,Hubei 430074,PRC);Assessment of Sustainable Development for Farmers——A Case Study in Niekou Village of Qinhuangdao City[J];湖南农业科学;2012-01
China Proceedings of conference Full-text Database 1 Hits
1 ;The Exploration of the Methods of Agriculture Sustainable Development Index[A];[C];2015
【Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 8 Hits
1 LIU Haiqing(College of Geography and Environment Science,North West Normal University,Lanzhou 730070,China);Energy Analysis and Sustainability Assessment on the Ecological-economic System of Lanzhou City[J];干旱区资源与环境;2008-05
2 ZHAI Hongjuan1, CUI Baoshan1,, WANG Ying2, WANG Juan1, ZHAO Xinsheng1, HU Bo11.State Key Joint Laboratory of Environmental Simulation and Pollution Control, School of Environment, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 1008752.Shandong Bureau of Coal Geological Exploration, Taian 271000;Ecosystem sustainability assessment of Yilong lake wetland and time-lag effects analysis of the PSR model[J];环境科学学报;2008-02
3 HUANG Bao-Rong1,OUYANG Zhi-Yun1,,ZHANG Hui-Zhi2,ZHENG Hua1,XU Wei-Hua1,WANG Xiao-Ke1 1 Research Center for Eco-environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100085,China2 Institute of Soil Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008,China;Eco-environmental sustainability assessment of each province in China[J];生态学报;2008-01
4 XU Jian-Ying~1,CHEN Li-Ding~(2,*),L Yi-He~2,FU Bo-Jie~2 (1.College of Resource,Environment and Tourism,Beijing Key Lab.of Resource & Environment and GIS Capital Normal University,Beijing 100037,China;2.State Key Laboratory of Urban and Regional,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Science,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100085,China).;Sustainability evaluation of the Grain for Green Program based on participatory rural appraisal in Wolong Nature Reserve[J];生态学报;2006-11
5 XU Su-fang,ZHOU Yin-kang(Urban and Resources Department of Nanjing University,Nanjing 210093,China);EVALUATION ON THE SUSTAINABILITY IN LAND USE OF DEVELOPMENT ZONE——A CASE STUDY IN WUHU ECONOMIC AND TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT ZONE[J];长江流域资源与环境;2006-04
6 DU Bin~1 ZHANG Kun-min~1 PENG Li-ying~2(1.Department of Environmental Science and Engineering,Tsinghua University,Beijing 100084,China;2.Environmental Institute,China Renmin University,Beijing 100872,China);Analysis of New Edition of Environmental Sustainability Index (2005)[J];中国人口.资源与环境;2006-01
7 WANG Li-yan1 WANG Wei2 LIU Yi1 (1.Institute of Geographical Sciences and Natural Resources, CAS, Beijing, 100101,China 2.College of Resources and Environmental Science, Hebei Normal University, Shijiazhuang Hebei, 050016,China);Study of Ecologically Sustainable Evaluation of Zhangjiakou[J];中国人口.资源与环境;2005-03
8 MEI Yadong\+1,HONG Wei\+2,WANG Xincai\+2,JI Changming\+1 (1.College of Water Resource and Hydropower, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072,China;2.Changjiang Water Resources Commission, Wuhan 430010,China);EVALUATION ON SUSTAINABILITY OF FLOOD CONTROL AND HAZARD MITIGATION SYSTEMS IN THE MIDDLE REACH OF THE YANGTZE RIVER[J];长江流域资源与环境;2002-06
【Co-citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 YU Shengwen;LI Linjun;QIU Guoyu;School of Environment and Energy, Peking University;;Evaluation of the Eco-Civilization Construction of Shenzhen Based on Catastrophe Progression Method[J];生态经济;2015-12
2 Gao Ce;Wang Ji;Zhang Ling-yun;Gao Ji-guo;Guizhou Normal University,School of Geographic and Environmental Sciences;;Study on the ecological benefit and Significance of Returning Farmland to Forest in Fu County[J];林业勘查设计;2015-04
3 LIN Xueqin;WANG Dai;LIU Xu;College of Resources Environment and Tourism,Capital Normal University;Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research,CAS;;Eco-environment Response to Urban Spatial Expansion and Its Driving Forces in Beijing[J];生态环境学报;2015-07
4 LI Jing-wei;LIU Zhi-feng;HE Chun-yang;GAO Bin;Center for Human-Environment System Sustainability,Beijing Normal University;State Key Laboratory of Earth Surface Processes and Resource Ecology,Beijing Normal University;College of Resources Science & Technology,Beijing Normal University;;Assessing the Human-environment System Sustainability in China from 1990 to 2010 Based on Human Sustainable Development Index[J];自然资源学报;2015-07
5 WU Zili;GUO Zongfeng;WEI Qin;WANG Zhengjun;Key Laboratory of Aromatica Pland Resources Exploitiation and Utilization in Sichuan Higher Education;School of Life Sciences and Food Engineering,Yibin University;Beijing Key Laboratory of Plant Gene Resource and Low-carbon Environmental Biotechnology,Capital Normal University;School of Tea,Yibin University;;Spatial distribution characteristics and influential factors of Cinnamomum longepaniculatumforestry in returning grain plots——A case study in Cuiping district,Yibin city,Sichuan province[J];陕西师范大学学报(自然科学版);2015-04
6 ZHANG Jingjing;CHEN Yin;College of Resources and Environment,Gansu Agricultural University;;Optimization of PRA Survey Supported Pattern of Modern Agricultural Demonstration Garden Planning in Minle County[J];甘肃农业科技;2015-06
7 Zhang Zhaohui;Geng Yude;Zhang Jing;School of Economic & Management Shihezi University;College of Economics and Management,Northeast Forestry University;;Research on the Factors of Farmers' Response Wish towards the Next Program of Conversion of Cropland to Forestland[J];林业经济;2015-06
8 YU Qing-feng;ZHANG Xin;LI Xiao-dong;Anshan City Land Resources Survey and Design Institute;Land Requisition and Land Requisition Department of Anshan City;;Study on Land Use Evaluation in Development Zone——A Case Study of Anshan High-tech Industrial Development Zone[J];安徽农业科学;2015-19
9 LIAO Wei;GAO Chao;LIU Han-sheng;WU Yi-jin;Postdoctoral Research Station,Huazhong Normal University;The Soil and Water Conservation Monitoring Center of Hubei;Key Laboratory for Geographical Process Analysis & Simulation,Hubei Province,Central China Normal University;;RESEARCH ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF FARMERS INVOLVED IN SOIL EROSION CONTROL BASED ON LOGISTIC REGRESSION ANALYSIS——A CASE OF WESTERN HUBEI PROVINCE[J];长江流域资源与环境;2015-05
10 ZHAO Zhongrui;XIE Chuanqi;WU Tong;FANG Jiangping;Tibet Agricultural and Animal Husbandry College;;Tibet eco-economic system evaluation based on emergy theory[J];贵州师范大学学报(自然科学版);2015-02
【Co-references】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 GUO Cun-zhi;LUO Lin-lin;YE Ming;School of Economics,Nanjing University of Finance and Economics;;Empirical Analysis of Factors Influencing the Sustainable Development of Resource-based Cities[J];中国人口.资源与环境;2014-08
2 LIU Wei;Economics Department,Beijing Academy of Social Science;;Construction of Ecological Civilization Evaluation Index System in Beijing[J];国土资源科技管理;2014-01
3 Zhiyou LIU;Chunling PU;Zhiming YAN;Zhen WEI;Qiang LI;Xiaodong HUANG;Management College,Xinjiang Agricultural University;;Influence Factors of Urban Sustainable Development of Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region——with a Case of Urumqi[J];Agricultural Science & Technology;2013-11
4 ZHANG Lin1,2,XUE Bing2,LU Chen-yu1,ZHANG Li-ming2,3,GENG Yong2,SUN Lu2,3(1.College of Geography and Environment Science,Northwest Normal University,Lanzhou 730070,China; 2.Key Lab of Pollution Ecology and Environmental Engineering,Institute of Applied Ecology,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Shenyang 110016,China;3.University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100049,China);Study on the Spatial Comparison and Measurement of Urban Sustainability Based on AHP & GIS Approach——A Case of 35 Municipalities in Northeast China[J];水土保持研究;2013-02
5 CHENG Jin-hua1 CHEN Jun2 YI Xing-hua1(1.School of Economics and Management,China University of Geosciences,Wuhan Hubei 430074,China; 2.Marxism Institute,China University of Geosciences,Wuhan Hubei 430074,China);Research on Evaluation Indicators System of Ecological Civilization in Mining Area[J];中国人口.资源与环境;2013-02
6 ZHANG Le-qin1,Chen Su-ping2,Li Rong-fu2,XU Xin-wang1(1Department of Resource Environment and Tourism,Chizhou College,Chizhou 247000,Anhui,China;2Department of Economic and Trade,Chizhou College,Chizhou 247000,Anhui,China).;Kuznets curve of carbon emission from energy consumption in Anhui Province of East China based on co-integration analysis[J];生态学杂志;2012-07
7 WANG Hui, WANG Qi, ZHAN Xian-da;Study on the Evaluation Indicators System of Ecological Civilization[J];中国地质大学学报(社会科学版);2012-03
8 ZHOU Ming-yi(Institute of Forestry Survey and Planning of Guangdong Province,Guangzhou 510520,Guangdong,China);Research on evaluation of forest ecological civilization city[J];中南林业科技大学学报;2012-04
9 Qi Song;SZ sustainable development ability research basing on DEA mode[J];特区经济;2012-04
10 ;重点旅游城市旅游生态足迹研究——以桂林市为例[J];环境保护与循环经济;2012-03
【Secondary References】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 5 Hits
1 LING Li-wen;ZHENG Wei-xuan;College of Mathematics and Information,South China Agriculture University;;Construction and Research of the Ecological Competitiveness Evaluation Model of Guangzhou City[J];惠州学院学报;2015-05
2 WANG Zhi-qiang;LIU Zhi-you;Management School of Xinjiang Agricultural University;;Research on Comprehensive Evaluation of Large City in Arid Area Sustainable Development: Taking Urumqi City as an Example[J];天津农业科学;2015-06
3 HE YANZI;YANG JIE;WANG HUANFANG;Business school of Hunan technology university;;How to Develop Low Carbon Macroeconomic for Regional Province-Under the Carbon Emission Constraint——A Case Study in Hunan Province[J];西安电子科技大学学报(社会科学版);2015-01
4 HU Ben-tian;XU Bing-hua;School of Economics,Anhui University;;The Estimation and Structural Analysis on the Gross National Wealth——Evidence from Anhui Province[J];华东经济管理;2014-11
5 REN Zijun;XU Jian;School of Resources and Environmental Engineering,Anhui University;Environmental Protection Department of Anhui Province;;Establishment and evaluation on Hefei urban ecological competitiveness[J];安徽农业大学学报;2014-03
【Secondary Citations】
Chinese Journal Full-text Database 10 Hits
1 WANG Jun, CHEN Zhen-lou, XU Shi-yuan (Key Laboratory of Geo-information Science of the Ministry of Education, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062,China);INDEX SYSTEM AND MODEL FOR EVALUATION OF ECOLOGICAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY IN THE YANGTZE ESTUARY-COASTAL ZONE[J];长江流域资源与环境;2006-05
2 MA Rui-Jun~(1,2,3),JIANG Zhi-Gang~(1,2) (1.Key Laboratory of Animal Ecology and Conservation,Institute of Zoology,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100080,China;2.Graduate School of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100094,China;3.Hohhot Professional College,Huhhot 010051,China).;Impacts of environmental degradation on wild vertebrates in the Qinghai Lake drainage,China[J];生态学报;2006-09
3 DU Peng~(1),XU Zhong-min~(2)(1.Geography and Environment Science College of North-West Normal University,Lanzhou 730070,China;2.State Key Laboratory of Frozen Soil Engineering,CAREERI,CAS,Lanzhou 730000,China);Emergy Analysis and Sustainability Assessment of Ecological-economics System in Gansu Province[J];地球科学进展;2006-09
4 XU Pengzhu,QIN Boqiang,HORST Behrendt, HUANG Wenyu,YU Shumei & ZHANG Yongpeng (Nanjing Institute of Geography and Limnology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing 210008,P. R. China) (Leibniz Institute of Freshwater Ecology and Inland Fisheries, Berlin D - 12587, Germany);Nitrogen surplus of the upstream agricultural land of Lake Taihu and the eutrophication impact[J];湖泊科学;2006-04
5 LI Song,QIU Wei,ZHAO Qing-liang,LIU Zheng-mao(School of Municipal & Environmental Engineering,Harbin Institute of Technology,Harbin 150090,China);Applying Analytical Hierarchy Process to Assess Eco-Environment Quality of Heilongjiang Province[J];环境科学;2006-05
6 ZHAI Hong-Juan, CUI Bao-Shan~*, ZHAO Xin-Sheng, LIU Shi-Liang, HU Bo, YAO Min (State Key Joint Laboratory of Environmental Simulation and Pollution Control,School of environment, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China).;Spatial variability and distribution of soil nutrient contents along different environmental gradients of Yilong lake shore[J];生态学报;2006-01
7 Zhang Ying;Study on the Mechanism of Forest Bio-diversity Decrease and Its Protection Countermeasures in China[J];绿色中国;2005-12
8 MAI Shao-zhi~(1,2),XU Song-jun~2,PAN Ying-jun~2(1.Nature Reserve Management Office of Guangdong Province,Guangzhou 510500,China;2.College of Geography,South China Normal University,Guangzhou 510631, China);APPLICATION OF THE PSR MODEL TO THE EVALUATION OF WETLAND ECOSYSTEM HEALTH[J];热带地理;2005-04
9 FU Guo(Chinese Research Academy of Environmental Sciences,Beijing 100012,China);Study of Concept and Indicators System on Eutrophication Sensitivity Classification of Lake and Reservoirs[J];环境科学研究;2005-06
10 LIU Zi-xiong,ZHU Tian-hui~*,ZHANG Jian(Forestry and Horticulture College Sichuan Agricultural University, Ya'an 625014, China);Analysis on Communities of Soil Microbes Under Different Modelsof Forest Rehabilitation[J];南京林业大学学报(自然科学版);2005-04
©2006 Tsinghua Tongfang Knowledge Network Technology Co., Ltd.(Beijing)(TTKN) All rights reserved